To the Spouter from Stone Harbor who said: “Windfall profit taxes do not produce more oil. Just ask Jimmy Carter.” You are correct, taxes do not produce more oil, but they may cause companies to lower the price to the consumer, which would eat into, and lower or eliminate their windfall profits, thereby avoiding the tax. Carrot and stick, as old as commerce itself. It won’t please their investors, but I can live with that. Regular profits should be good enough for anyone. "Windfall" is just that, a piece of unexpected good fortune, by definition.